Current:Home > MyDebate emerges over whether modern protections could have saved Baltimore bridge-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
Debate emerges over whether modern protections could have saved Baltimore bridge
lotradecoin advanced analytics dashboard View Date:2024-12-26 01:59:38
When a 900-foot container ship struck the San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge in 2007, the span stood firm and no one died, either on the ship or the highway above.
The bridge’s supports were protected by a fendering system of concrete and other materials that was installed to absorb such strikes. And it’s now prompting the question: Could such a system — or others like it — have saved Baltimore’s Francis Scott Key Bridge?
Some experts are saying yes.
Sherif El-Tawil, a University of Michigan engineering professor, said there are several safety measures that “would have made a huge difference” had they been in place Tuesday morning when a cargo ship plowed into the bridge and caused its collapse.
El-Tawil said a fendering system may have softened the 985-foot-long ship’s blow. Pilings anchored to the river bottom, known as dolphins, are another measure that could have helped to deflect the container ship Dali. And yet another potential protection would have been islands of rocks or concrete around the bridge’s supports.
“It may seem like a very large force,” El-Tawil said of the massive cargo ship. “But I think you can design around it, either through a protective system or by designing the bridge itself to have massive towers.”
Such protections have become a focal point in the wake of the tragedy, which claimed the lives of six construction workers. Experts say the 47-year-old Key Bridge did not appear to have the protections that are common among newer spans.
The incident is raising questions about how much money American taxpayers are willing to spend to protect against these rare but deadly catastrophes. And not everyone agrees the Key Bridge could have been saved.
“There’s a lot of debate taking place among the engineering community about whether any of those features could have had any role in a situation like this,” U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg said Wednesday at a White House briefing.
“It’s difficult to overstate the impact of this collision we’re talking about,” Buttigieg said. “It’s not just as big as a building, it’s really as big as a block —- 100,000 tons all going into this pier all at once.”
Buttigieg did not directly answer a question about whether steps should be taken to protect the nation’s bridges. But the secretary noted that many bridges have been designed to better protect against collisions since a freighter struck Florida’s Sunshine Skyway Bridge in 1980, killing 35 people.
Baltimore’s Key Bridge opened three years before that disaster in 1977, a time when cargo ships were much smaller in size. In recent years, vessels have grown to carry more containers to save on shipping costs. Ports in Georgia and South Carolina have dredged deeper channels to accommodate them, while part of a bridge was elevated to allow bigger ships to reach New York City-area ports.
The Skyway Bridge disaster in Tampa prompted a paradigm shift in design in the early 1980s, said Mark Luther, a University of South Florida oceanography professor and director of the USF Center for Maritime and Port Studies.
The new Skyway Bridge was built with rock islands around its main supports and large cylindrical piers on either side of those islands to make it “very difficult for a vessel to strike any part of the bridge and knock it down,” Luther said.
“To go back and retrofit a bridge like the Key Bridge with these features would be extremely expensive,” Luther said. “And to my knowledge nobody’s done it. (They’ve) just had to accept what risk there is with the construction that was state-of-the art in the ‘70s.”
Roberto Leon, a Virginia Tech engineering professor, said the technology exists to protect a bridge against a collision with a massive cargo ship like the Dali.
But he cautioned that governments will always be weighing the costs and the risks. And the protections put in place don’t always match up to the size of the disaster, even if the Key bridge was retrofitted with modern safety measures.
“This was an enormous load,” he said of the ship that struck the Key Bridge. “If the protection system had been designed for that load. I think it would have protected the bridge. But a big question is: Would you design it for such an enormous load? Because as the load increases, it becomes much more expensive.”
veryGood! (7)
Related
- Wally Amos, 88, of cookie fame, died at home in Hawaii. He lost Famous Amos but found other success
- “Shocked” Travis Kelce Reacts to Taylor Swift’s Concert Shoutout
- Texas wants the power to arrest and order migrants to leave the US. Can it do that?
- Biden announces 5 federal judicial nominees and stresses their varied professional backgrounds
- Stuffed or real? Photos show groundhog stuck inside claw machine
- Taliban minister attends meeting in Pakistan despite tensions over expulsions of Afghans
- Corruption and Rights Abuses Are Flourishing in Lithium Mining Across Africa, a New Report Finds
- Robin Roberts Reacts to Michael Strahan's Good Morning America Return After His Absence
- Family of man killed by Connecticut police officer files lawsuit, seeks federal probe of department
- China’s economy shows sparks of life, despite persisting weakness in troubled real estate sector
Ranking
- Conservative are pushing a ‘parental rights’ agenda in Florida school board races. But will it work?
- Donald Trump's Truth Social has lost $23 million this year. Its accountants warn it may not survive.
- Missing sailor sent heartbreaking final message to his family during Hurricane Otis, wife reveals
- Two have died in a Utah mountain plane crash and a third who was injured got flown out by helicopter
- As Baltimore’s Sewer System Buckles Under Extreme Weather, City Refuses to Help Residents With Cleanup Efforts
- Ohio interstate crash involving busload of high school students leaves 6 dead, 18 injured
- After controversy, Texas school board says transgender student can sing in school musical
- NFL power rankings Week 11: Stars are bright for Texans, Cowboys
Recommendation
-
US unemployment claims fall 7,000 to 227,000 in sign of resiliency in job market
-
Why Fig.1's Micellar Cleansing Wipes Are My New Skincare Holy Grail
-
Donna Kelce Reveals How Son Travis Kelce Blocks Out the Noise
-
Live updates | Israeli tanks enter Gaza’s Shifa Hospital compound
-
Usher Cancels Atlanta Concert Hours Before Show to Rest and Heal
-
Glen Powell Addresses Alleged Affair With Costar Sydney Sweeney
-
Energy Department tries to boost US battery industry with another $3.5 billion in funding
-
Sammy Hagar tour: Van Halen songs on playlist for Michael Anthony, Joe Satriani, Jason Bonham